Rebel News reporter Avi Yemini demands $250,000 by Monday Nov. 23 from Victoria Police for two unlawful arrests. His lawyer Justin Quinn has set out the claim in a letter Yemini has put on the public record; see below.
TO Chief Commissioner Mike Bush Victoria Police Victoria Police Centre GPO Box 913 Melbourne VIC 3001
Dear Chief Commissioner
Avi Yemini – arrests in Melbourne CBD on 12 November 2026
We act for Mr Avi Yemini, a journalist with Rebel News. Urgent – by email Adelaide Canberra We write in relation to the student protests held outside State Library Victoria, Melbourne on 12 November 2026. Our client attended that event as a journalist to interview attendees and report on matters of public interest.
At around 3:30 pm, our client was peacefully interviewing attendees when a Victoria Police officer asked him to move approximately 100–200 metres down the road for his safety, the protesters’ safety and police safety. The officer identified no specific threat or disturbance and did not identify a legal basis for requiring him to move.
Our client declined because he was peacefully reporting and there was no apparent lawful requirement to move. Four professional security personnel accompanied him as a safety measure. The same officer returned within about a minute and again asked our client to move. The officer then ordered junior officers to arrest our client. Officers tightly handcuffed our client behind his back, forced him into a divisional van and drove him several blocks away before releasing him. Footage is available
Our client rejoined his security team and was returning to the protest to continue his journalism. At around 4 pm, while our client remained several hundred metres from the protest, officers formed a line across his path. A Victoria Police officer told our client that, if he crossed the line, he would be arrested for hindering police. That officer gave our client a conflicting account of our client’s first arrest, telling our client that our client was merely detained. Our client told the officer that his earlier arrest had been unlawful and asked what grounds there would be for arresting him again. Despite those enquiries, the officers did not identify the duty he would allegedly be hindering or explain how his conduct would hinder it. Our client was arrested again, taken to Melbourne West Police Station and released without charge.

Avi Yemeni in VicPol van (photo supplied)
Footage is available at Our client is in possession of more footage of both arrests and your officers’ inappropriate behaviour. This footage clearly backs up our client’s version of events and shows that the officers in question were acting inappropriately and unlawfully. During both arrests, excessively tight handcuffs left both wrists swollen and one bleeding.
The officers’ physical handling also reinjured our client’s shoulder, which had recently recovered from an injury. On neither occasion was our client aggressive in any way and nor did he threaten anyone or create a disturbance.
First arrest
The first arrest and detention constituted false imprisonment because the officers had no lawful basis to arrest or detain our client. Our client’s refusal to comply with any purported move-on direction did not provide that basis: refusal to comply with an unlawful direction is not an offence. Section 6(1) of the Summary Offences Act 1966 (Vic) requires reasonable grounds for a move-on direction, including grounds relating to an actual or likely breach of the peace, danger to another person’s safety or behaviour likely to cause injury, property damage or another risk to public safety. However, no such grounds existed.
Our client was peacefully undertaking his work as a journalist, was not violent or threatening, and was neither being threatened nor in danger. Therefore, no reasonable basis for any purported move-on direction existed, and any refusal by our client to comply with such a purported direction did not constitute an offence. Accordingly, there was no basis for arresting our client for his refusal, and no basis for reasonably believing that his arrest was necessary under s 458(1)(a) of the Crimes Act 1958 (Vic).
The circumstances did not support a reasonable apprehension of an imminent breach of the peace and did not show that arrest was necessary to prevent one. The physical handling and handcuffing of our client also constituted battery. The unlawful arrest provided no justification for the force used, which was clearly unreasonable in the circumstances.
Second arrest
The second arrest and detention also constituted false imprisonment because the officers had no lawful basis to arrest or detain our client. Our client’s attempt to return to the protest to continue his public interest journalism did not constitute hindering police in the execution of a lawful duty or breaching a lawful no-return direction. Section 51 of the Summary Offences Act prohibits obstructing or hindering a police officer in the execution of duty. However, no such hindering or obstruction occurred. The officers did not identify the lawful duty allegedly hindered or explain how his conduct hindered it.
The officer’s assertion that our client had been ordered not to return did not establish a lawful basis for his arrest. Any earlier purported move-on direction lacked reasonable grounds for the reasons set out above, and no fresh grounds for restricting his movements were apparent. Therefore, no basis for alleging an offence of hindering police or refusing to comply with a lawful direction existed, and there was no basis for reasonably believing that his arrest was necessary under s 458(1)(a) of the Crimes Act. The physical handling and handcuffing during the second arrest also constituted battery.
The unlawful arrest provided no justification for that force, which was unreasonable in the circumstances. Recurring police conduct It is deeply concerning that these arrests are not isolated incidents and occurred even after our client previously received a written apology for Victoria Police acting in a similarly unlawful manner.
In the attached written apology of 27 June 2022, Victoria Police acknowledged that our client had been wrongfully arrested and detained while reporting for Rebel News on 26 January 2020, 5 September 2020 and 26 January 2021. It apologised for the resulting hurt and embarrassment. Our letter of 9 October 2026 raised a further incident in which an officer grabbed our client by the throat and personally threatened him while he covered the “Vigil for Gaza” on 7 October 2026.
That matter apparently remains under investigation by Professional Standards (ref: CLASS-2/842/2026) even though it occurred over 5 weeks ago and footage of your officer’s inappropriate and unlawful conduct was provided. That incident and the subsequent investigation should have prompted greater awareness and effective corrective action.
Victoria Police officers are expected to de-escalate situations and use lawful force only where necessary, not impede lawful journalism through excessive force. That this unlawful conduct continues to occur raises serious concerns about repeated interference with our client’s ability to undertake public interest journalism at protests and events in Melbourne. Concerns Notice This is a Concerns Notice issued under Part 3, Division 1 of the Defamation Act 2005 (Vic) (the Act) and equivalent legislation in other States and Territories. Our client has been defamed by Victoria Police’s statement provided to journalists including 3AW’s Madelaine Burke in response to a query about our client’s arrest on 12 November 2026. The statement was reproduced in Ms Burke’s X post published through @Madelaine_Burke on 14 November 2026 at 2.58 pm. The post is available at https://x.com/Madelaine_Burke/status/2121452636386066509, and a screenshot of the statement is below in Annexure A.
Although the statement did not name our client, it was supplied in response to a query about his arrest and presented in that context. Readers familiar with that context would understand it to concern him. Imputation The statement conveyed the following defamatory imputation, or an imputation not differing in substance: Our client wilfully committed the criminal offence of hindering police in the execution of their duty. Our client denies that imputation.
Serious harm
Our client considers that publication of the statement has caused, or is likely to cause, serious harm to his reputation within the meaning of s 10A of the Act. It attributes criminal conduct to our client in the course of his work as a journalist, undermining his professional reputation.
The statement failed to mention that the direction and subsequent arrests were unlawful. The allegation carries particular weight because it comes from Victoria Police.
The statement was supplied to a journalist for 3AW, one of the largest radio stations in Melbourne, making wider media and social-media republication a natural and probable consequence and increasing the likelihood of serious reputational harm.
Publication and malice
Victoria Police published the statement by providing it to Ms Burke in response to her queries about our client’s arrest. Our client considers that the statement was malicious. It appears that the statement was made to protect Victoria Police’s reputation in circumstances where Victoria Police must have been aware that our client’s arrest was unlawful.
This is particularly upsetting to our client given that he previously accepted an apology for unlawful arrests, only for similar conduct to recur and be followed by a statement portraying him as the offender.
Proposed resolution
Having now served the above Concerns Notice, it will be open to our client to commence defamation proceedings after the applicable period of 28 days has elapsed, pursuant to s 12B of the Act. Our client has a clear basis to pursue civil remedies against the State of Victoria and, to the extent permitted by the Victoria Police Act 2013 (Vic), the officers responsible.
However, our client is willing to resolve his civil claims arising from both arrests on 12 November 2026 by way of a full and final settlement if Victoria Police:
1 pays $250,000 in compensation;
2 pays our client’s reasonable legal costs incurred in relation to these claims;
3 provides a written apology acknowledging the wrongful conduct and its impact on our client; and
4 conducts a full investigation into both arrests and the conduct of the officers responsible, and implements necessary corrective measures, including training on the lawful exercise of police powers, appropriate use of force and interactions with journalists reporting at protests and public events.
Our client considers these measures sufficient to resolve his civil claims arising from both arrests and detentions on 12 November 2026.
Please confirm as a matter of urgency whether Victoria Police agrees to this proposal and, if so, how and when these measures will be implemented.
Our client’s rights concerning the separate October matter remain unchanged. This proposal does not affect any requirements to investigate or take disciplinary action. No release will take effect unless a resolution is agreed and implemented.
Please bring this letter to the attention of the relevant operational commanders and Professional Standards Command.
Our client remains willing to engage constructively with Victoria Police to resolve this matter without proceedings.
We look forward to your urgent response by Monday, 23 November 2026.
Yours sincerely Justin Quill | Partner, Thomsons
COMMENT by Andrew L. Urban
Press freedom is as fundamental to democracy as freedom of speech. When the apparatus of State attempts to prevent or hinder such press freedom, it is in violation of democracy. It is also a violation of democracy when police fail to protect the public from intimidation and threats of physical abuse by rioting socio-politically inspired demonstrators.